« KidVid Tournament 2008: The Bracket | Main | There's Another KidVid Matchup Today »

KidVid Tournament 2008: Orange Sherbet vs. Eric Herman

Leading off the KidVid Tournament 2008 is a matchup from the Woody Guthrie Region -- the #2 seed "Campfire Song" from Orange Sherbet with help from Hot Buttered Rum (off their Campfire Sing-Along CD versus the #3 seed "My Lucky Day" from Eric Herman (off Snow Day!).

Vote in the comments below. One per family, please. Votes due by 9 PM West Coast time.

"Campfire Song" - Orange Sherbet with Hot Buttered Rum

Watch here (broadband link here)

"My Lucky Day" - Eric Herman

Comments

Eric Herman, easy choice.

They're both so sweet and lo-tech. Dig.

My Lucky Day gets our vote.

I vote for "Campfire Song." "My Lucky Day" made me smile (& it's a nice surprise ending after the credits), but I'm a sucker for woodland animals and campfires. I liked how they each had a buddy. :)

Put down one more vote for "My Lucky Day" it really is very cute.

Two kids in my house, one vote each for Campfire Song and Lucky Day. The littlest liked Campfire Song and the oldest liked My Lucky Day.

Both are excellent but My Lucky Day gets the edge for animation and shining optimism. Tough choice.

Two whalopping kid votes for "Campfire Song" by Orange Sherbet with Hot Buttered Rum! We're big sherbet fans! ( ;

My votes is for "Campfire Song." Fun animation and aweseome vocals. My young daughter gives the vote for Campfire Song too - can't get better then that.

Definitely Orange Sherbet with Hot Buttered Rum!!!!

I vote for Campfire Song as my kids just love that one.

They're both great, but our household is voting for Campfire Song...

Campfire Song. Brings back nostalgia for the campfires and great outdoors of childhood. Great song with a great sound. And part of a GREAT album!

"Campfire Song"
I just loved drawings and the variety of instruments... especially the fiddle.

campfire song. we love it!

I like the Campfire Song a whole lot. It had a good ending, not like the other one where he is stuck in the hole.

Henry, age 4

One vote here for "Campfire Song." Love 'em both but I'm a huge fan of Orange Sherbet and Hot Buttered Rum!

Myles

Campfire Song !!!

My vote is for Campfire Song by Orange Sherbert

Our household votes for "Campfire Song" by Orange Sherbet. Love the mellow pace of the song and the creature visuals.
gillian & gary

Orange Sherbet for us please!

CAMPFIRE SONG - AWE-SOME!! We listen to it (and the whole CD, in fact) over & over....

We love "Campfire Song"! Go Orange Sherbet!!!

Kathy, ChaCha & Ceci

Lucky day is nice but Campfire song is just AWESOME! Sherbet all the way.

We vote for orange sherbet please!

Campfire Song! Love OS & HBR...thanks!

Orange Sherbert for sure

"Campfire Song"! Orange Sherbet! Yeah!!!!

Griddle

My Lucky Day!

"We can't get to that Campfire too soon!!! Break out the S'mores!

orange sherbet!

Waaaaay Campfire Song by 17 miles!

"Campfire Song" by Orange Sherbet! Great song and wonderful animation.

Campfire song! More Butter, more Orange Sherbet! MMMMMM.

our little bear just loves
orange sherbet
he howls for it all the time

Orange Sherbet! Orange Sherbet! Orange Sherbet!

My Lucky Day! :)

Wow! What fun!

We (7 and 3 year old) vote for the campfire song!!!!!

My Lucky Day

Orange Sherbert!

Very cute, catchy song with fun graphics and clever ending!

My Lucky Day!

My Lucky Day

I have to say "My Lucky Day". The animation is cute and simple, but as happy as the song is. :) Do want!

My Lucky Day FTW! It's awesome.

Eric :-)

Campfire Song by Orange Sherbet & Hot Buttered Rum!

One vote and four big thumbs up for Orange Sherbet (2 adult thumbs and 2 little-big-boy thumbs). Hard to beat Orange Sherbet with a little Hot Buttered Rum!

CAMPFIRE! Our family loves and votes for Campfire!

Add another vote for "My Lucky Day"!

Eric Hermann, My Lucky Day!Woo Hoo!

I vote for Eric Herman's My Lucky Day!

Orange Sherbet rocks in "Campfire Song"!

All three of my kids voted for Lucky Day!

Yep! It's My Lucky Day! Go Eric!

Eric Herman, My Lucky Day!
Thanks!

My kids say Campfire!

"My Lucky Day." Huzzah!

Another vote for campfire!!!

Campfire!

CAMPFIRE Songs - we love Orange Sherbet and HBR, Yay Marshmellows!

There is nothing better than a Campfire, except an Orange Sherbet inspired one!

Orange Sherbert gets my vote!

Campfire Song gets our vote!

Campfire grooves and yodels! And groovin' and yodelin' gets my vote anytime.

my kids vote for campfire!

Campfire Song!

Orange Sherbet Orange Sherbet Orange Sherbet! Yay campfires!

OK, time's up. It was a spirited competition, a first-round match for all time, but Orange Sherbet and Hot Buttered Rum's "Campfire Song" takes the matchup.

Definitely Lucky Day in my book. Love Eric's stuff (I mean my kids love his stuff)

Eric Herman has my vote. Loved it.

Campfire SOng fo sho! THis is a wonderful and cute video and also a fantastic song. Right on!

Orange Sherbert with Campfire Song gets my vote!

hands in the air, a rousing fireside vote for campfire song!!!

LUCKY DAY 6 votes from this house!

Yeah Orange Sherbert and HBR. It is almost Campfire time!

My vote goes to Orange Sherbets Campfire Song!!!

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)